Tennessee’s Amendment 1 Would Leave Key Pretrial Problems Unresolved

Tennessee’s Amendment 1 Would Leave Key Pretrial Problems Unresolved

In a Buffalo River Review op-ed, serious concerns are raised that Tennessee’s Amendment 1, which would expand judges’ authority to deny bail, would not address the broader issues contributing to public-safety concerns in the state. While the amendment would allow pretrial detention without bail in additional serious criminal cases, the piece contends that many problems stem from defendants being released without meaningful financial accountability, inadequate enforcement of release conditions and lengthy delays in resolving cases.

 The article argues that Tennessee should focus on strengthening accountability in the pretrial system, including requiring financial security when appropriate, enforcing release conditions and moving cases through the courts more quickly. It also cautions against enshrining a policy change in the state Constitution when the underlying problems may be better addressed through improvements to court administration and existing procedures.

 Below is an excerpt from the op-ed as well as links to the full opinion piece.

AMENDMENT 1 WILL NOT FIX TENNESSEE’S CRIME PROBLEM

Tennessee voters will be asked this November to make a significant change to the state Constitution. Amendment 1 would expand the circumstances under which judges could deny bail, allowing pretrial detention without bail in a substantially broader range of serious criminal cases.

Supporters present Amendment 1 as a tougher response to crime. But Tennessee should ask a more basic question before changing its Constitution: Will this amendment actually address the problem that is driving concern about crime in the first place?

There is a serious problem with the way some defendants are being released before trial. But it isn't that Tennessee lacks the constitutional authority to keep every dangerous defendant behind bars. It is that defendants who have been arrested can sometimes be released with little or no financial security, minimal conditions and months to wait before their cases are resolved.

That is a very different problem.

The defendant who is arrested, released and then arrested again before the first case is even set for trial is not an unusual constitutional question. It is a problem of accountability and a criminal-justice system that can move too slowly.

Tennessee already gives judges the authority to impose conditions on release and to require bond. What has proliferated in some communities is what might better be called unaccountable release: defendants released on their own recognizance, token conditions that are difficult to enforce and cases that remain unresolved for months.

READ THE FULL ARTICLE HERE>>>

THE ARTICLE MAY ALSO BE ACCESSED HERE>>>

Read more